Earlier today I dropped my Toronto election ballot in the local mailbox.
I voted for Olivia Chow to return as Mayor of Toronto because I think that she is, by far, the better of the two remaining serious candidates.
Am I head-over-heels impressed with her transit policies? Not entirely, but she believes in transit, more and better transit.
So far, the programs coming down the road, so to speak, are Chow’s proposed fare reduction through a weekly cap at 10, on top of the already planned monthly cap of 40 likely going into effect in September 2027. But, as I wrote recently, there is much more to making transit attractive than twiddling with the fare structure.
We hear a lot about capital investment for the future with the help of federal and provincial subsidies: the Waterfront East and Eglinton East lines, new subway cars for Line 2 Bloor-Danforth. But the needs are even greater with no sense of how we will pay for everything both for state of good repair and on the wish list of additions and enhancements.
Operating costs and subsidies see no discussion, and indeed fare cuts will trim revenue. It’s good politics and good policy to make transit easier to use by everyone, but “easy” includes not just the fare but also the service.
A dispiriting part of any transit mega-project is the “benefits case” where a major offset to capital spending is the alleged travel time saving of new lines. The hours saved are translated to notional dollars, but what really happens is that public investment turns into time that riders can use for other things. It also translates to massive stimulus for the engineering and construction industry.
Oddly enough, the same equation is not applied to day-to-day service in the hands of fiscal hawks who see transit as a drain, not as an investment. This is an argument the Mayor must champion: transit provides a public benefit to the city’s economy.
I have no illusion that Mayor Chow will shower the TTC with new money, in part because she (or any other Mayor) faces the imminent expiry of the Ontario “New Deal” funding that pays for operation of Lines 5 Eglinton and 6 Finch. There is talk of a “New Deal 2.0”, but nothing definite yet.
But transit service – quantity and quality – must improve, and that is a challenge for the Mayor and Council. The next TTC Board must demand that management provide clear information on system performance and real improvement riders can see in their daily travel.
Chow will not find this easy, and her priorities for housing and social services may well trump new transit spending. However, Bradford’s priority for transit does not lie in service, but in massive spending on security. Yes, there is an issue with unsocial behaviour on the TTC, but it must be addressed by more than a large police presence. It is also, I believe, over-hyped for political reasons, a common problem not just in Toronto’s transit debates.
There is no point in having a heavy police presence if people still cannot get on the Dufferin bus.
The choice of TTC Board members is key, and we need aggressively pro-transit Commissioners who will hold management to account for system performance and advocate for real improvements, even if this cannot be achieved in one year. I believe that Chow will drive for such a Board, while Bradford would focus on penny-pinchers whose relationship to transit lies mainly in complaining about being stuck behind a bus or streetcar.
Toronto’s election and its future turn on two contrasting views of our city. One assumes that tax cuts will solve everything and public services should be farmed out to private ownership and management. The other believe in public service and the good local government can provide to a wide range of its citizens.
My vote’s with Olivia Chow.
My vote is with Olivia too!
LikeLike
You openly endorsed Josh Matlow last time against Olivia, Olivia will not forget.
Steve: I thought Josh was better then. Now, (a) he’s not running and (b) Olivia has proved herself as mayor, (c) Bradford would be a disaster borrowing madly and selling off city assets to pay for tax cuts.
LikeLiked by 2 people
First, Chow is the least bad option on transit among frontrunners. I can’t see why I wouldn’t vote.
Second, I say this as a white collar professional: transit fares are too cheap, and Chow’s focusing on keeping them low is hurting the TTC. We need to increase TTC funding, and the farebox is a great way to do that. Any increase in fares must be tied to broad relief programs for those who need them. That includes increasing the Fair Pass program, having effective daily, weekly, and monthly caps, and then investing the new fare money into better service.
Better service can also mean cheap things like removing the asinine stop sign at the beginning of the new Scarborough busway, increasing enforcement against those who block streetcars, changing operating policies so our streetcars aren’t the slowest in the world, and more expensive things like installing bus lanes, having the political courage to rebuild Line 1’s outdoor sections, and installing platform edge doors now rather than over the next 500,000 years.
My choice to take the TTC is compared against Uber and biking. $3.30 is too “expensive” for a 20 minute bike ride in the middle of July. I save money and also time, the latter being more important. The TTC is also a ridiculously small fraction of the cost of Uber for most trips, though the analysis changes if I’m travelling with a friend. Raising the base fare to $5 will almost never change the analysis. Again, this should be coupled with robust programs so that frequent riders and those with financial need get relief. This could mean improving Fair Pass, offering discounts for using Presto, improving the daily/weekly/monthly caps, etc.
For comparison, single tickets in New York cost 5, London 5.85, Paris 4, Berlin 6.4, Vienna 5.12, Barcelona 4.64, and so on. All values converted to CAD. Toronto’s tickets are cheap for GTA standards, let alone global.
LikeLike
Totally agree on every point, Steve.
There is no perfect candidate, but Chow is as close to one as we’re being offered.
There’s risk in ‘neutral’ commentators declaring their choice of candidate. There’s even more risk in not declaring.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I voted for the former federal Conservative minister Christopher Alexander. I will be filing a lawsuit against this incompetent FOOL for wasting my vote and time, he dropped out after I had already voted for him in advance – people like him should be banned from ever holding public office. I am in the anyone but Olivia campaign after the last 3+ years of disaster under her regime.
LikeLike
If you are referring to Steve, he has never painted himself as neutral, non-partisan, or unbiased. But what risk are you taking about? There are many a people who think that they have a great amount of influence but as they find out every election, all of their influence equals exactly ONE VOTE. All they get is ONE VOTE, there is no risk.
Steve: I have my opinions, and many people ask what they are. Will I swing any votes or just reinforce what my readers already think. I might not have much influence broadly speaking, but I have no delusions about my reach, or not. There are trolls who leave some truly ugly posts in comments here that don’t get published. I don’t expect to change their minds or waste my time “debating” their drivel.
What I do know is that I am regularly contacted for both public and private comments on transit issues, and am respected for my opinions and experience.
LikeLike
Caronto is a mess, or sure feels like it, and we have better odds with Ms. Chow, though we still have major issues with out-voting of the core by the more ‘carservative’ areas, let alone the province stomping us again, or undercutting options like a Vehicle Registration Tax, which technically is still possible, but a $500 fee per vehicle wouldn’t fly too far, though it could also lower property taxes, thin out congestion, and ensure more housing sites on already serviced land.
LikeLike
Steve Munro doesn’t use paint. He objectively posts and analyses *figures* and *charts*. ‘Reference’ in other words.
If you fully believe that, then why are you arguing?
LikeLike
Hans: What risk are you talking about?
Stephen Saines, it sounds to me that you are the one who is arguing. You stated that there are risks when “neutral” commentators like Steve publicly endorse a candidate and that the risk is even greater if they don’t endorse anyone. Hans asked you what the risk was but instead of answering his question, you started to argue and accusing Hans of arguing when you are the one who is arguing. I am sorry to say Stephen Saines but you don’t sound reasonable neither in your original comment nor in your response.
Steve: The “risk” is that I will have trolls making snotty comments about what a loser I am to support Chow. Water off my back. It is no secret that of the two candidates, I prefer Chow to Bradford, although I think she could improve on the transit file. But there is only so much money to go around.
LikeLike
Using Barcelona as example, though, reveals that only single fares are expensive relative to Toronto. Below is for zone 1 only (which includes pretty much the whole city) in CAD. 10-ride ticket (can only be used by one person at one time) is 20.77. Family ticket 8-ride that can be used by multiple people at the same time and has to be used within 30 days 18.37. Multi-person ticket for 70 rides over 30 day period (from first validation) 145.37. Personal ticket for unlimited travel for 30 days from first validation 36.42. Unlimited travel card (aimed at tourists, if bought online, time measured from first validation) 18/1 day, 27/2day, 39/3 day, 51/4 days, 63/5 days. There is also a discount ticket for people under 30 73/90 days from first validation.
We don’t have that many different options with such discounting. We have 5c off when not using cash and cap after 47 rides (meaning you essentially need to spend 155.10 before you get any free rides).
LikeLike
Me too! I wish though Olivia focused her campaign more on improving the transit like signal priority and removing slow zones rather than the constant emphasis on the 10 rides then it’s free.
I’m disgusted with the anti-transit, anti-bus lane rhetoric Brad and Parthi and others are pushing. They are so misleading about the bus lanes. They are using Kennedy/Midland for votes but they aren’t telling people that the plan is to remove them anyway once the busway opened. These fools won’t say that as they want to continue the divisive rhetoric. Eglinton/Kingston/Morningside ones are working and carry several different routes and serve so many marginalized communities. I’m so disgusted that these politicians are now wanting to rip them up and make transit worse for all of us.
LikeLike
This is precisely why I stated multiple times that we need relief programs for those in need and those who ride frequently.
Barcelona also has a noted tourist influx, some would say over tourism, which presents an interesting problem for policy makers. You want to set the price as close as possible to the point at which that tourist will take an Uber, because once they take the Uber it’s worse for everyone, but since they don’t need your vote there’s little incentive for them to pander to the low end of the potential fare range. The daily cost of the tourist card is far higher than the (now defunct) day pass in Toronto that was naively ended based on the idea that 2 hour transfers solve all of the world’s problems.
LikeLike
I agree with your choice.
LikeLike
Good for you. Olivia Chow has done a great job for Toronto from social services to better TTC. John Tory’s Toronto was horrendous.
LikeLike
I agree with you. Brad doesn’t have my vote when he suggested refunds for subway delays. It was around the time the work-cars were leaking on the tracks. It shows that he doesn’t understand how the fare system works for the TTC. For GO transits it’s tap on tap off. So anyone issuing a refund can see you were on a delayed trip and process the refund accordingly. But the TTC you can tap once and not tap again the entire journey going in and out of a paid fare zone.
LikeLike
I appeal to all faithfuls of stevemunro.ca to vote for change if you are not happy with the status quo. People keep voting for the status quo and then wonder why things don’t change. My friends, if you want change then please go out and vote for the change you deserve.
Steve: The vote that put Olivia Chow in office three years ago was a vote from the change of the Tory/Ford years, and we need more of it.
LikeLike
The weird thing with Chow is even though it seems like there’s not a lot of inspiring progress on the transit file, the reality is that just by building the Scarborough busway, she’s built more transit infrastructure than the last two mayors combined. She might be the only modern mayor to build any significant piece of transit infrastructure on-budget and on-time. She has a solid track record of just quietly getting things done on the transit file. While other mayors spent a lot of time talking about transit, Chow just quietly built a busway in record time without a lot of hoopla. Just judging by the amount of YouTube videos in my recommended feed by random people, it almost feels like the busway is more popular than line 6. By objective measures, she’s probably the strongest mayoral candidate on crime, budgets, poverty reduction, and transit in decades. It just doesn’t feel that way for some reason.
LikeLike
I’m not enthusiastic about either candidate. But the fact that Chow no longer uses the TTC (as she stated in a recent debate) may explain why she seem oblivious to the decline of the system since Byford left.
Still, as someone stated above, she may be the least bad choice. Which is sad, from a transit enthusiast’s perspective.
LikeLike
I support Olivia Chow and she has my support but I would like to correct your statement by saying that she has built more than the last THREE mayors combined. Even Ford and Tory built some stuff but Miller had two terms and built absolutely nothing though he was good at drawing lines on the backs of napkins.
Steve: David Miller “drew” Transit City as more than lines on a napkin. When he came into office, Toronto had no overall rapid transit plan. Ontario was pulling together what became the Let’s Move plan, and Transit City was created as such a plan. It was sandbagged by Rob Ford who didn’t want anything to do with a Miller plan.
The choice of LRT was based on two factors: likely demand on the network, and the limited funding that would be available in the Big Move plan.
LikeLike
Hi Steve, This is more of an afterthought after I saw that Gil Penalosa has endorsed Bard Bradford. He has endorsed Chow last time, and when he did run earlier against Tory, I remember your article 4 years ago where you had voted for him. I remember you saying you knew Tory would win, but this is a protest vote. (Of course there was no chow or even Matlow in the race then). I would love to know your thoughts.
Steve: Gil is entitled to his opinion, but I am very disappointed to see him supporting Bradford. Chow isn’t perfect, but I have seen enough of Brad’s nasty side to dislike him. Stir in the cast of ne’er do wells who are supporting him and we could have an Executive Committee like the worst of the Ford days.
LikeLike
Though not quite related to the post at hand, I find it amusing that Bradford Bradford is not only a graduate of the same program at UWaterloo as me – Urban Planning, ironically – but made the same obnoxious reputation among our professors then as he enjoys (and we put up with) now.
LikeLike
I have reasons to be all over the city and sometimes residents come up to me to talk about a problem that they are having. (It’s usually Not My Department, but anyway.)
I try to give them advice, but it usually boils down to “Call 311”. When they say that doesn’t work, I suggest “Call your councillor,” and this year, “Call your councillor, it’s election year”.
I was somewhere by Kingston Rd and Dundas when I resorted to the above.
The resident just snorted, and said “The councillor is Brad Bradford! He’s only in it for himself!” (There may have been more, but the second sentence was memorable.)
So I guess I was in Bradford’s ward.
Brad-Brad. is councillor for Ward 19, Beaches-East York.
Notably, for the 2023 mayoral by-election, Brad lost his own riding. He got 1723 votes. Josh Matlow beat him with 1737 votes. Anthony Furey beat him with 1874 votes. Mark Saunders beat him with 2099 votes. Ana Bailao trounced him with 10429 votes. And Olivia Chow took 15910 votes, almost ten times B-B’s numbers.
Interesting to consider what the residents of the ward that Bradford represents might think of him as mayor.
Steve: They are monumentally unimpressed.
LikeLike
Straphanger wote,
At least Toronto and London only have 2 (TTC & GO, or bus/tram and Underground/Overground/National Rail) fare systems to deal with. As opposed to somewhere like Tokyo where, as great as the rail network is for coverage (the average walking distance from home to a train or subway station is about 800 m), the fare structure of the network as a whole is a fractured mess.
In the 23 Special Wards that make up the main urban part of Tokyo, vs. the Tama Region in western Tokyo which, while it has some fairly sizeable cities of its own, has nowhere near the population or transit density of the 23 Special Wards, there are (if I haven’t missed any):
As a practical example, when I was looking at apartments when I was going to language school there, one place I looked at was about a 15 minute walk to school. But if it was bad weather, and I wanted to take the bus, I would’ve had to take 2 buses run by different operators, costing, IIRC, 230 and 210 Yen (C$2.03 and C$1.85), and, between waiting for the buses and the buses taking somewhat circuitous routes, taking slightly longer than walking.
LikeLike