Joe Mihevc, Vice-Chair of the TTC, has posted an update on Youtube regarding the long, complex story of this project.
According to him, the station should re-open for normal service in the last week of March.
Let’s hope that gremlins don’t push that off to April 1, although somehow I feel that would be an appropriate date.
There is a post on youtube by Joe Mihevc, Vice-Chair of the TTC, showing the situation at St. Clair West Station that has kept streetcars out of the loop for months.
When the contractor started to excavate to install a new expansion joint, they found electrical cables buried in the concrete that were not on the station plans. These are being rerouted.
I talked to the Vice-Chair last week, and the TTC hopes to have the streetcars fully back into the station in about a month.
I spoke to Vice-Chair Joe Mihevc at the TTC meeting on Wednesday about the situation at St. Clair West and on the portion of the line east to Yonge. Here is the current status.
The problem with rebuilding the track is that there is one section on the east side of the loop where there are electrical cables buried in the concrete. Breaking up the concrete so that these can be moved is a delicate business and won’t be done for a few months. Meanwhile, the rest of the loop is being installed.
In about two weeks, this will allow pavement restoration in most of the loop. At that point, the buses that enter from the west will be able to loop down the ramp and around the west and north sides of the platform. They will all exit via the ramp that comes out in the Loblaw’s building on the north side of the street.
Meanwhile, Mihevc is getting a complete runaround from staff on the installation of new shelters. It’s always something that will happen in a week or two, and has been like this since the summer. He is getting very frustrated because he takes the blame every time he parrots information to his constituents.
TTC staff should carefully consider what they are doing. Mihevc has defended staff positions on the St. Clair right-of-way against all criticisms and burned up some of his credibility, with me among others, in the process. The last thing the staff needs is to lose that champion in the Vice-Chair’s office. If he stops believing what he is told, they are in big trouble.
Of course, many of us stopped believing what staff said about St. Clair a long time ago. Vice-Chair Mihevc has some catching up to do.
Chris W. sent in the following comment:
Hooray! The St. Clair Transit website was updated today! There is a new, very informative flyer.
Highlights:
- Phase 2 (Westmount to McRoberts) to start October 15 and continue into the spring.
- Vaughan Road to Westmount Avenue to start next spring.
- Caledonia to Gun’s loop to start late next summer.
- Shelter installation on Phase 1 to start early October 2007!
- Later this fall streetcars will returns from Yonge to Oakwood loop, initially running straight through St. Clair West Station.
- Streetcars will be removed in spring 2008 “With other TTC work occurring on Bathurst Street “. Could this mean the tracks from Bloor to St. Clair will be replaced next year instead of 2009?
If this all comes to pass someone should throw a party.
Yes, I believe that Bathurst from St. Clair down to Bathurst Station is supposed to be rebuilt in 2008. Continue reading
While I was at the TTC today, I took the oppurtunity to find out what is going on with this endless project. Here’s an update.
The Ramps at St. Clair West
Due to problems with the contractor (no specifics), the work has been on hold. However, the impasse is now resolved, work has (or will shortly) resume and completion is planned for the end of October.
The New Shelters
The now-and-forever project to install new shelters on the completed portion of the line is getting rather comic. They were supposed to come in August, then in September and now they might get here this month, but don’t hold your breath. October, maybe. Considering how long ago this line was designed, the idea that we are only now getting delivery of the shelters is a huge joke.
Why Are The Buses Not On The Right Of Way?
It seems that the buses are afraid of falling off because of clearance problems. Of course, if they hadn’t put those dumb centre poles on the right-of-way, this would not be an issue.
I cannot help thinking that all of these and similar problems are rooted in what passes for design and project management. The TTC can run an efficient project (just look at the recent reconstruction at Kennedy Station), but some on some projects everything that can go wrong does. They can’t blame it all on SOS or Hydro.
Ray Kennedy writes:
Why doesn’t the TTC take advantage of the current bus substitution to extend service west to Jane Street? This would allow a chance to judge demand for extending the tracks westward.
During a previous substitution I waited on a Saturday afternoon nearly half an hour at Gunn’s Loop for a 71 Runnymede bus to go west to Runnymede to transfer again. 3 buses accumulated in the loop before finally making their way eastward one at a time. Then, 2 more showed up and sat waiting time. Finally, a Runnymede bus showed up. It would have been quite possible for one or two of the five buses to run west rather than sit in the loop. It’s called service.
Bus substitutions are always tricky things to schedule and often have a lot of padding in the running time. Right now, there really isn’t much going on on St. Clair, and they will always be early. In some cases, they will run more or less as the operators feel like it because leaving on time just means a dreary, slow ride across the line.
The TTC’s attitude to this part of the world (the old stockyards) is a good example of how they don’t actively promote ridership. If St. Clair from Keele to Jane is a potential streetcar line, then there should be a lot more riders than the level of service on the 71 suggests. Indeed, that service (really a short turn of the longer route), does little to encourage transit use in an area where the land use is changing a lot.
We hear a lot about a “Transit First” policy, but even without recent budget woes, it’s the small neighbourhoods like this that are overlooked.
City Council, in its infinite wisdom, overturned the recommendations of their staff and of the Community Consultative process set up to review the design of the St. Clair LRT project.
Although the original design for Dufferin and St. Clair did not include an east-to-north left turn lane, this feature has been added by Council direction. See the Decision Document at item EY7.38 for details.
The staff report on the subject includes drawings of both configurations, and you can see clearly the degree of curb cuts that this decision will entail at an already-crowded intersection.
Two follow-on actions were included in the Council decision:
This decision bows to those who drive on St. Clair by providing a left turn at the expense of pedestrian space. Once the construction is finished, we can expect to hear howls of outrage about this change.
On Thursday evening, July 12, at 7:00 pm, there will be a special meeting of Etobicoke-York Community Council at York Council Chambers to discuss the design of the St. Clair and Dufferin intersection.
Please note that erroneous information has appeared elsewhere stating that this meeting will be at the Etobicoke Civic Centre. This is incorrect, and if you schlepp out to Burnhamthorpe and The West Mall, you won’t find any meeting.
The background for this meeting is that the proposed configuration for this year’s construction on St. Clair is opposed by “Save Our St. Clair” for the elimination of the east to north left turn lane at Dufferin. The TTC/City proposal uses this space for an eastbound nearside safety island and, by doing so, avoids a major curb cut on the southeast corner. Continue reading
No, this is not a commentary about immigration, but about the seemingly mundane issue of street lighting, hydro and TTC poles on St. Clair Avenue.
Regular readers here will know that I am not impressed by designs including centre poles because:
People involved with the project from both the City and the TTC have steadfastly maintained that these poles are essential to the project and that they were “selected” by public participation. This is complete nonsense on both counts. Continue reading
The TTC will install new shelters on St. Clair starting in late July. They are currently at the stage of approving drawings for the manufacture of the shelters, then there will be a prototype, then the installation.
I can’t help wondering why on a project that has seen so many delays we are only just now getting around to the preliminary stages of building the shelters. This is one more example of a project with equal measures of bad luck and bad planning.
On a brighter note, I was at a community meeting tonight regarding the detailed plans for this year’s construction between Westmount and McRoberts, and things went much more smoothly than the raucous gatherings of earlier times.
Update May 9: The presentation materials are available online.
Steve Munro 