TTC Board Meeting: January 19, 2023

The TTC held a regular Board Meeting on January 19 with a rather light agenda.

Although there was the usual CEO’s Report, there was no discussion on the item. In past articles I have written about the shortcomings of this report, and that ties in with a major item later in the agenda.

The second report and presentation covered subway and streetcar closures for capital works in 2022 with details of the 2023 plan and a brief outlook into 2024. My article about this report has been updated with a few new maps and clarifications.

There was one deputant who spoke about facilitating subway replacement shuttles with paid duty officers and TTC staff to direct traffic, and the need for TTC to have more powers to do this so that they can supplement the available police. This evolved into a discussion of special constable powers that wandered quite substantially from the topic under discussion. It never really addressed the basic concern that subway shuttles can be mired in traffic.

One Commissioner asked about posting more information about projects, and for a moment I hoped this would turn into a discussion about the chaotic state of public information and operation of replacement services. Alas, the interest was more in the usual “good news” type of publicity saying to the public “look at the great maintenance we are doing”. Riders just want to know where to find reliable replacement service through the blizzard of outdated or inaccurate notices that appear both in hard copy and online.

At the beginning of a new Board’s term, an important briefing covers the duties and responsibilities of Board members under various law and regulations, notably the duty of care for safety of employees and passengers. The presentation was given by the TTC’s General Counsel, Michael Atlas, and the Chief Safety Officer, Betty Hasserjian.

It is not sufficient that the Board know that management is regularly monitoring and auditing the organization, but that there is a reporting mechanism to ensure the Board knows what is happening. This is supposed to occur via the CEO’s Report, but past experience shows that the Board rarely questions whether the data, the Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) in that report tell a complete and accurate story. This shows up commonly in the wide gap between the quality of service riders complain of constantly and the much rosier view in the CEO’s Report.

In the course of her presentation, Hasserjian noted that the reporting requirements for major incidents on the system were approved by the Board in July 2021. What she did not mention was that this came after a big wake-up call to the Board when they discovered that a “near miss” between subway trains had occurred in June 2020 at Osgoode Station, but it was not reported to the Board until the story surfaced in the Toronto Star on June 4, 2021.

See: The “Near Miss” At Osgoode Station

There was a presentation on the incident in a private session of the Board on June 16, 2021 at which they approved the following:

That the TTC Board direct the Chief Executive Officer to alert the Board when an incident meeting the identified thresholds for escalation occurs and subsequently report to the Board once a comprehensive review or investigation has been completed.

The new policy was presented at the July 2021 public meeting.

The TTC has implemented an Escalation and Notification Protocol, which requires that the Board be advised of all incidents that meet the following criteria:
1. Any Level 3 investigation. Level 3 investigations are conducted for our most serious incidents under the supervision of Senior Management and review and approval by the Executive. For occupational incidents, these investigations will address incidents where the amount and type of hazardous energy involved would most likely result in a fatality. For customer or public incidents, the consequence would be multiple fatalities.
2. Any near miss of revenue trains on the mainline.
3. Any safety investigation involving a 3rd party review.
4. Any matter at the discretion of the CEO or Chief Safety Officer.

It is truly astounding that such a policy was not already in place, and that it took a “near miss” plus a year’s delay and media reporting to trigger its inclusion. One small but key word in point four is “or” that allows the Chief Safety Officer to bypass the CEO.

Needless to say, there was nothing in the CEO’s Report presented at the July 2020 Board Meeting about the incident.

The fundamental point about “oversight” by a Board of Directors is that they have an active role. It is not to micromanage day-to-day operations, but to set policies and directions, and to ensure that there are reliable mechanisms in place for them to monitor how these are carried out.

This is summarized in Atlas’ presentation at page 5 where he lists the typical involvement of Directors of a corporation:

  • strategic planning
  • risk management
  • oversight/supervision of management
  • organization‘s values and policies
  • ensuring obligations to stakeholders are understood and met
  • major corporate decisions

Sadly the TTC Board does very little of this work preferring to rubber stamp management proposals and assume that all is well. One glaring problem, particularly concerning in today’s financial situation, is that past attempts to form a Budget Committee or to organize a meeting simply to discuss overall corporate direction have foundered for lack of interest.

There is an Audit & Risk Management Committee, and it does review management plans and performance, to the degree that these are reported. This is an exception to a generally laissez faire attitude.

The Board should not trust that all is well until the next crisis appears out of the blue on the front pages.

5 thoughts on “TTC Board Meeting: January 19, 2023

  1. Steve, the 996 ops have been doing all the heavy lifting on York Mills. Malvern ops are purposefully running behind them and letting them pick up all passengers, what is their problem???

    Although its good to finally see some frequent service on York Mills between Kennedy and Yonge. Buses come around every 5 mins now during weekdays.

    Steve: When I get the January tracking data, I will look at how the merged service is operating. This is a problem in more than one area where branching services (even on the same route) do not merge together on the advertised even headway.


  2. Steve, do you know what’s going on with the New Flyer Hybrid order? And do you know if these will replace the last Orions in the system?

    Steve: No. I have to chase TTC to get an updated fleet plan based on what is in the new capital budget.


  3. Will the vehicles operating on the Eglinton and Finch West lines be considered expenditures in the Streetcar or Subway category? It will be interesting to see the operational aspects and cost of the Alstom Citaldis equipment on Finch WestOH LOOK, the O-train has broken down again!!

    Steve: They really should be broken into a separate category so that “streetcar” or “subway” costs for fully owned and operated lines are not mixed in with lines where the cost is partly contracted (operating) and partly assumed by others (provincial payments for capital repairs).

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Wonder what year or month will the water main break at King & University [will] appear in as a footnote at the TTC board meeting? The escalator is out of service until February 4th, luckily in 2023 (subject to change, of course).


  5. Is the Chief Safety Officer reporting a Level Three Investigation when the TTC puts on a Covid Super-Spreader Event with a bus that is unsafely crammed full?

    Steve: Surely you jest. First, the TTC would have to acknowledge that they have buses that are packed full. Second, they would need to acknowledge that this is a safety concern. Third, they would have to get the Board to roll back the loading standards which went back to “normal”, more or less, once ridership sufficiently recovered. That plan was implemented quite some time ago and has not been revisited.

    The degree of accepting responsibility you imply greatly exceeds what we are likely to see.


Comments are closed.