A New TTC Board With Big Challenges

At its meeting on November 19, Toronto Council recreated the TTC Board for the 2026-30 Council term. The Board was formerly composed of 10 members, with 6 Councillors and 4 “citizen” members. This has been reduced to 4 and 3 respectively in keeping with downsizing of other boards in the past Council term.

In the 2022-26 term, the Board’s membership was:

CouncillorsCitizens
Jamaal Myers, Chair
Paul Ainslie
Alejandra Bravo
Deputy Mayor Ausma Malik
Josh Matlow
Dianne Saxe
Joe Mihevc, Vice-Chair
Fenton Jagdeo
Liane Kim
Julie Osborne

Myers and Saxe failed to win re-election on October 26, 2026.

Although citizen members had time left in their appointments, these are “at pleasure”. On Mayor Chow’s recommendation, their appointments were rescinded effective immediately. The City Clerk will conduct an “expedited” process to fill the vacancies because the Board’s first meeting is planned for December 15. This process has not been announced, but in order for Council to make the appointments before December 15, this would have to be concluded by December 9-10, the next Council meeting and the last for 2026.

It is unclear which of the existing members will reapply for the new term and be successful, as opposed to an infusion of new blood onto the Board.

The new Board is:

CouncillorsCitizens
Paul Ainslie, Chair
Alejandra Bravo
Mike Layton
Neethan Shan
Three to be appointed

The Vice-Chair is chosen by the Board from the Citizen members.

The new Board faces severe financial problems because of the potential withdrawal of special Provincial funding that supported operation of Lines 5 and 6, not to mention general increase in TTC costs, a planned further improvement to the fare capping scheme, and calls for better service. This effect was show in the 2026 operating budget’s projection of 2027 and 2028. (Note that proposed extension of the fare capping program in 2027 is not included in this table.)

Equally grave is the situation with CEO Mandeep S. Lali who is the subject of two recent articles from TorontoToday:

The first article deals with an investigation launched in September in response to complaints of inappropriate workplace behaviour. The second details the population of senior roles up to, effectively, the Deputy CEO by consultants including a firm that was created, apparently for the purpose, just before Lali was appointed. A related issue is an April 2026 request by Lali that the Board increase the limit on his ability to award untendered, sole-source contracts from the current $500,000 to $5-millon. This request was deferred on a motion by then-Chair Myers, and has not resurfaced.

One must ask how attentive the old TTC Board has been to its management. It was no secret that Lali has been resented for his managerial approach, but nothing concrete has come out until now. Sour grapes after an external appointment are not unusual, but the situation described by TorontoToday goes well beyond that.

After years of demoralization and the loss of many senior staff under former CEO Rick Leary, the hope for the new era was review and rejuvenation. Instead we have another CEO whose effect has been dubious, at best, and who has further extended a rudderless era in Toronto’s transit.

Postscript

Added November 19 at 10:30pm:

For the benefit of the trolls who have nothing better to do than leave uninformed, insulting comments, two facts you should already know:

  1. I do not have any ambition to sit on the TTC Board and have said so repeatedly both here and when asked about doing so by fairly senior politicians. Being a Board member would bring requirements both for confidentiality and for supporting decisions I might not agree with. As an outsider, I can have better sources of information, the freedom to write what I want, and the ability to interact with various agencies, community groups and media without wearing an “official” hat of a Commissioner.
  2. Anyone who thinks that I would be barred from appointment because I “didn’t support Olivia” has not been paying attention. I wrote an article before the election saying why I had voted for her. In 2023, I supported Josh Matlow, but that is water under the bridge.

Meanwhile, I archive all of the bilge that passes for informed comment from many allegedly different userids, including the source IP addresses which are surprisingly few.

8 thoughts on “A New TTC Board With Big Challenges”

  1. Hi Steve, Happy that the new ttc board has some pretty known pro transit faces.

    2 questions for you:

    How far down the line can they kick the can of frozen fares ? It seems that the more they delay the more the fares have to increase.

    Steve: Theoretically, they can defer fare increases forever, but at an annual cost in increased subsidy of $50 million assuming a 5% increase on a revenue base of $1-billion. Meanwhile, inflationary costs on the total $3-billion plus budget will add around $100-million annually on the cost side without even considering additional service or new lines. It’s impossible to get back to the 1/3 subsidy, 2/3 fares and ancillary revenue ratio because of the combined effect of repeated fare freezes and ridership that is still below pre-pandemic levels.

    Also I see a lot of people biking and using bike share Toronto. Has that had any effect in ridership in the downtown core … compared to pre pandemic?

    Steve: I suspect it has shaved the top off of potential riding growth for short trips, but recently strong growth in streetcar usage has been reported by TTC. The bigger problem is that service is so screwed up with multiple construction projects that it drives riders who have a choice away from the system and they’re hard to get back.

    Like

  2. Sole sourcing a large contract or set of contracts and creating a consultant-heavy special group within upper management seems like a problem.

    The alleged HR concerns around being rude to staff, if true, seem like a problem.

    The glacial improvements to signal priority seem like a problem.

    The useless platform fences, which echoes the CEO leading a similar wasted effort in New York City, seem like a problem.

    Not sure CEO Lali can continue to have the confidence of the board.

    Steve: I agree, but how long will the situation fester given that there’s nobody obvious to take over.

    Like

  3. The TTC fares all need a fare increase, to cover the cost increases in fuel (both electricity and diesel). MINIMUM should be equal to cost of living. As long as there will be an increase in service at the same time, across the board. Should take effect at the same time as the 10 rides weekly cap.

    Like

  4. The Mandeep Lali situation appears to be more of a deeper issue compared to the allegations about Rick Leary. Consultation firm that’s friends with Mandeep and only started 6 days before Lali got the job. And to the point of taking over many managerial jobs. That will definitely rub people the wrong way. On top of the allegations that been leaked. We can only imagine what more is going on.

    This is a good opportunity for the TTC to start fresh with a new CEO. Which aligns with a new council term. A new CEO could easily be a former manager that use to work for TTC. Even the temp CEO we had last year. I don’t think it’s hard to find someone that is capable, and Canadian. There was talk of Adam Giambrone being CEO. Imagine that. I’m sure there’s plenty of potential CEOs brushing up their resume right now.

    I was hoping Josh Matlow would be on the TTC board and the new TTC chair. We’ve seen him grill management. I can only imagine what he would have down with these allegations against Mandeep Lali.

    It will be interesting to see what response we get from Mandeep Lali. And if he resigns or forces TTC to remove him. Either way, it will be a pretty penny to get compensate him.

    This also comes at a time when most union contracts at TTC expire next year, plus budget talks, agreements with the province, presto contract expiring, etc.

    Steve: I’m not sure about Giambrone as CEO. He has political baggage from his time on Council and at the TTC Board, and that would cloud his role even though it’s in the past. The question is whether there is a trusted former TTC manager, one of the many we lost during the Leary era, who would want to come back.

    Like

  5. Matlow says he was dumped for his commentary on the platform fences…

    So much for TTC Board independence and reason…it might be a long four years here if she isn’t going to take advice from people she is aligned with and have the best interests of the TTC at heart.

    Steve: Nothing prevents Matlow from showing up at a Board meeting as an independent Councillor and commenting on matters they are discussing, albeit not in camera items. The geographic distribution of the four TTC Councilors is odd. Two from central Toronto and two from Scarborough. Those from North York and Etobicoke might feel slighted, almost as if they “deserve” more.

    Like

  6. When I worked for the TTC, I remember rumours circulating that the CEO at the time, Greg Percy, was gunning to make his interim role permanent.

    Makes me wonder in how different of a position we would be if that had happened. The grass over there doesn’t look very green, but its a different shade than here.

    Steve: My concern about Percy was/is that he didn’t appear too interested in challenging the holdover Leary policies, even if he was an interim CEO.

    Like

  7. Well, as for past managers coming back to TTC, I know Jim Ross would be a good candidate, he worked his way up the ranks. Collie Greenwood also worked his way up through TTC, also ran MARTA until Trump got in as President. Kirsten Watson, another who worked her way up the ranks as well would be a great candidate, and apparently well respected at TTC. Eve Wiggins also had a short run with Mississauga transit and worked at Metrolinx. All have Canadian experience, aware of TTC needs and could hit the ground running. If I recall, they all were managers under the beloved Andy Byford as well.

    Like

Leave a Reply